Financial model and numbers
Valuing a startup with little or no revenue
Short answer
A startup with little or no revenue is valued by comparison and by working backwards, not from profits. Use three methods together: the scorecard method adjusts the typical value of similar deals; the venture capital method divides a future exit value by the return an investor needs; a milestone checklist gives credit for progress. The result is a range for negotiation.
Why the usual methods fail
Established companies are valued on profits or cash flows. A young company has neither, so investors price the probability of a large outcome. That is a judgement, and it is settled by negotiation.
Method 1: scorecard
Start from what comparable companies at your stage and location raised at. Adjust for how you compare.
| Factor | Weight |
|---|---|
| Team | 30% |
| Size of market | 25% |
| Product and technology | 15% |
| Competitive position | 10% |
| Sales and channels | 10% |
| Need for more funding, other | 10% |
Score each from 50% (much weaker) to 150% (much stronger), multiply by the weights and by the typical value.
Method 2: venture capital method
Work backwards from an exit.
- Estimate the company's value at exit.
- Divide by the return the investor needs.
- Reduce for dilution from later rounds.
- Subtract this round to get the pre-money value.
Example, illustrative: exit value ₹500 crore, required return 15x, founders and early investors keep 60% through later rounds. Post-money today = 500 ÷ 15 × 0.6 = ₹20 crore. Raising ₹2 crore implies ₹18 crore pre-money.
Method 3: milestone checklist
Give credit toward a local ceiling for each milestone: a sound idea, a working prototype, a strong team, key relationships, first sales. It is crude, and it stops founders over-valuing an idea with nothing behind it.
Use the range
The three will disagree, often widely. That is the point: it shows which assumptions carry the valuation. Take the range into the conversation, know which end you would accept, and know what else you would trade for it.
What actually sets the price
Demand. If two investors want the deal, the valuation moves up. If one does, it is their number. Preparing well and approaching investors in parallel does more for valuation than any formula.
Try the three methods in the valuation estimator.
Quick answers
Can I use discounted cash flow?
Not usefully before revenue. The forecast is too uncertain, so the answer depends entirely on assumptions.
What matters more, valuation or dilution?
Dilution. A high valuation with a large round can still cost you more of the company than a modest valuation with a small one.
Do I need a valuation report?
For negotiation, no. For issuing shares, the law can require a report from a registered valuer or a merchant banker; ask your company secretary or chartered accountant.